top of page
Search

Why “New Year, New You” Often Doesn’t Work — And What Does

Clock strikes midnight New Year

Every January 1st, millions of us wake up inspired, determined, and hopeful: this year will be different. We vow to eat better, move more, sleep more, stress less, and build habits that will change our lives. Yet research shows that most New Year’s resolutions don’t survive long past February. In fact, around 80% of people abandon their resolutions within the first month of the year.


So why does this annual tradition fall short so often?


1. We Try to Change Too Much at Once


One of the biggest psychological traps is tackling multiple big lifestyle changes all at once. Trying to overhaul your diet, start a fitness routine, improve sleep, and eliminate habits like sugar or social media all at once creates cognitive overload. Our brains aren’t built to focus on too many new behaviors at the same time; trying to do so can quickly lead to burnout and abandonment of all of them.



Experts point out that this tendency to bite off too much, coupled with all-or-nothing thinking, is a key reason resolutions fail. When we hold ourselves to perfection (“I must exercise every day!”), a single slip can feel like total failure, and motivation crumbles.



2. Habits Take Longer to Form Than We Think


Popular culture once told us that habits take 21 days to form but science says otherwise. Systematic research finds that new behaviors typically take 2 to 5 months to become automatic, and in some cases nearly a year.


This means expecting instant habit mastery in January is unrealistic. When we don’t see immediate results, motivation drops and if we’ve piled on too many new habits at once, it all becomes overwhelming.



3. Timing and Stress Matter

January isn’t just another day: for many it’s cold, dark, and stressful. Financial strain from holiday spending, post-holiday blues, and seasonal demands can sap our mental energy exactly when we’re trying to adopt new habits.


All these factors create a perfect storm that makes big changes harder to sustain.



How to Start New Habits Well

Science-Backed Strategies That Actually Work

If trying to change everything at once often fails, what’s the better way forward?


Focus on One Behavior at a Time

Instead of a long resolution list, choose a specific, small habit that feels achievable and aligned with your values. For instance, rather than “get healthier,” commit to walking 20 minutes three days a week or drink one extra glass of water daily. Small changes lower psychological resistance and make success more likely.


Be Realistic With Time

Remember that habit formation is a process, not a deadline. Expecting mastery in a few weeks sets you up for disappointment. Instead, pace yourself, think in months, not days.


Build Habits Into Your Environment

Automate success where you can. Lay out workout clothes the night before, put your journal next to your bed, or set a bedtime alarm. The easier the behavior is to do, the more likely it is to become routine.


Track Progress and Adjust

Instead of rigid perfection, look for consistency and gradual improvement. Setbacks aren’t failures just data that guide your next step.



Live Seasonally

Align Your Growth With the Year’s Rhythm

Another way to think about change is not as a January sprint, but as a seasonal cycle. Just as nature moves from winter dormancy to vibrant spring growth, so can your personal growth ebb and flow with the seasons. Here’s what that might look like:


  • Winter: Reflection and restoration - focus on rest, gentle routines, and planning next steps.

  • Spring: Emergence and growth - begin building momentum on the habits you chose.

  • Summer: Expansion and action - deepen habits as energy rises.

  • Fall: Harvest and refinement - reflect on what worked and recalibrate.


By pacing your goals with the rhythm of the seasons rather than forcing everything at the start of January you allow yourself space to grow sustainably and adapt naturally.



Ready for Spring Growth? My Nordic Inspired Seasonal Wellness Program Starts March 2nd! If you’re excited to approach your health and wellbeing the right way with patience, ancestral habits, and seasonal pacing. I’d love to support you.


✨ My Spring Program begins March 2nd, designed to help you build sustainable routines, increase clarity, and grow gradually in a supportive community.


Let’s make growth feel joyful, doable, and lasting together.



Sources




University of South Australia. "Myth busted: Healthy habits take longer than 21 days to set in." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 24 January 2025. Retrieved from www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2025/01/250124151347.htm







Comments

bottom of page